*For CPT patients* Please note that we are not physicians and are not providing medical advice. Results presented in this survey are reflective of the conditions of the ladies who have responded. We do not mean to imply that their treatment history will be the same for you. We present this data so that you can be better informed about treatment options, and be able to discuss those options with your personal physician.
The most surprising result was a change in the most often reported age range for first collapses. From 91 respondents, 31 women reported this age as less than 32. This option was selected by a margin of two to one over all other options. Just two years ago, the most commonly reported age was 39-41 years, which was consistent with the scientific literature. Now it appears that women are being diagnosed much earlier than just a few years ago. A similar trend was seen in the age at which women are reporting CPT symptoms. With the vast amount of information on-line, it is reasonable that both patients and their doctors are more familiar with the condition, so that women are being diagnosed at an earlier age.
Survey results continue to indicate that treatments which include a plan to address the endometriosis are more successful than treatments which involve thoracic surgery alone.
38 of 91 respondents reported a collapse-free status of 6 months or less. Of these, 5 reported no treatment, 25 reported thoracic treatment alone as their most recent, 2 reported thoracic surgery combined with hormonal treatment, and 3 were no longer menstruating due to surgical or chemical menopause.
53 of 91 women reported a collapse-free status of one year or more. Of these, 2 reported no treatment, 16 reported thoracic treatment alone as their most recent, 3 reported thoracic surgery combined with hormonal treatment, 2 reported bio-identical hormone therapy and 30 were no longer menstruating due to surgical or chemical menopause. Of the 16 who reported thoracic treatment alone, 3 noted that while they remain collapse-free, they continue to have monthly chest/back pain.
As mentioned above, 2 women reported the use of bio-identical hormone therapy in order to treat endometriosis by balancing the hormones. One reported the use of pharmacy compounded bio-identical progesterone. The second reported the use of the Sottopelle bio-identical hormone implants. Both women reported a collapse-free status of 3+ years without pain, although they continue to menstruate.
26 of 91 women reported the use of synthetic hormones to stop menstruation (Lupron, Zoladex, Depo Provera, continuous birth control pills, etc). Of these, 15 reported a collapse-free status of 2-3 years.
15 of 91 women reported either a full oophorectomy (both ovaries removed) or a full hysterectomy (both ovaries and uterus removed). Of these, 4 reported a collapse-free status of 1-2 years and 10 reported a collapse-free status of 3+ years. The one women who reported a collapse-free status of 1 month also reported that she started on synthetic hormone replacement therapy (HRT) immediately following her oophorectomy, and has since continued to have collapses. A second woman in the one- year category also corresponded with us, reporting that she too continued to have collapses when HRT was taken immediately following surgery. Since discontinuing HRT therapy, she has remained collapse-free. A third woman in the three-year category also reported that four months after her oophorectomy she had to have a second surgery to remove ovary remnants which had inadvertently been left and had caused menstruation to resume. This example further illustrates the importance of complete ovary removal for the purpose of treating CPT.
As can be surmised by the treatment choices of many women who have taken this survey, suppression of endometriosis by stopping the menstrual cycle remains a key point. Whether it be with Lupron or ovary removal, the goal seems to be estrogen suppression. Many doctors understand this purpose in performing an oophorectomy, and encourage patients to wait at least 6 months before starting on any HRT. However, some obviously do not understand the dynamics of endometriosis, and prescribe estrogen therapy immediately following surgery, thereby defeating the whole purpose of removing the ovaries in the first place.
Overall, surgical menopause still shows the best success rate in preventing collapses if HRT is initially withheld. Of the 14 women who followed this treatment, all of them remain collapse-free, most well over the 3-year mark.
Additional survey results showed, as expected, a trend of pelvic endometriosis and related menstrual problems. Many women experienced menstrual symptoms in their teens and 20's before being diagnosed with abnormalities in their late 20's or 30's. Approximately 43% of the respondents had used birth control pills or other progestins to treat menstrual problems.
For now, we hope these results give you and your doctor something to talk about. We greatly appreciate the ladies who took the time to share their stories with us, so that we could share them with you!
January 2011
|